Accepted Items & Limits

Remember, We are The PICKY Chick…..Please only bring your best.

Pick-y:  /ˈpikē/    (adj)  meticulous, choosy, attention to detail, careful about choosing or accepting things.

Please don’t be offended if an item is rejected…. we all miss things in the rush to get everything prepared.

We are a seasonal sale. This means we only accept spring/summer items for the SPRING event & fall/winter items for the FALL event.


Item Limits

Regular Consignors
350 items MAX
250 regular/100 restock

Restock Consignors
200 items MAX

Regular Consignors
15 Item Minimum
15 items to participate

Restock Consignors
15 Item Minimum

Regular Consignors
20 Pair Shoe Limit
10 regular/10 restock

Restock Consignors
10 Pair Shoe Limit


Regular Consignors
20 Book Limit
20 books/bundles

Restock Consignors
20 books/bundles

Accepted Items

  • BOY CLOTHING: Preemie to size 18/20
  • YOUNG MEN’S CLOTHING:  Up to size XXL and 38 waist, ONLY brands listed below
  • GIRL CLOTHING: Preemie to size 18/20
  • JUNIORS CLOTHING:  Up to size XXL, size 17 and 36 waist, ONLY brands listed below
  • SHOES up to size 12
  • BABY ACCESSORIES: Diaper bags (not freebies from hospital), bibs, hats, shoes, socks, bottles, slings, receiving blankets, swaddlers, bottles (remove used nipples), feeding & bathing equipment
  • BABY EQUIPMENT: High chairs, pack & plays, strollers, swings, bouncy seats, excersaucers, jumparoos, walkers, etc
  • NURSERY FURNITURE: Cribs (must meet 2011 Child Safety Standards manufactured post 6/28/2011) changing tables, rocking chairs, toy boxes, desks, toddler beds, twin beds, children’s furniture
  • BEDDING: Child themed full or twin bedding, sheets for cribs, pack n plays, bassinet, toddler bed
  • LARGE TOYS: play kitchens, table w/chair sets, sandboxes, slides, play houses
  • RIDING TOYS: Power Wheels, bikes, wagons, tricycles, scooters
  • ANYTHING LITTLE TIKES, STEP 2 or similar climbing structures and slides
  • PLUSH ANIMALS: ONLY Build-a-Bear or similar animals & clothing. And ONLY stuffed animals that “do something”- sing, dance, make sounds
  • DVD’s (up to “appropriate” PG-13 Only), CD’s (no explicit lyrics), books(Imagination Library books should be donated vs. selling them), parenting books, puzzles, board games, video games
  • Ipod, Ipad, Wii, Xbox 360 or newer, Nintendo, Play Station, Leapster, etc
  • All TOYS: infant, toddler, preschool, big kid. Must have working batteries.
  • LEARNING MATERIALS: Home school curriculum, unmarked workbooks, manipulatives,
  • PRETEND PLAY: “Dress-up” clothing & accessories, costumes (Halloween specific costumes only in Fall)
  • ALL SPORTS EQUIPMENT: Attire, equipment and accessories for dance, gymnastics, tumbling, cheer, twirl attire & accessories. Baseball, T-ball, basketball, soccer, football, swim, skate, skateboarding, (snowboarding/skis in Fall Sale)

Unaccepted Items

  • NO worn under clothing, new or unopened under clothing is OK.
  • NO stains, tears, or out-of-date clothing
  • NO Adult style clothing or shoes.
  • NO maternity clothing
  • NO Adult themed books (romance novels, thrillers). Parenting books OK.
  • NO Stuffed animals (Build-a-Bear and plush toys that “do something” are OK)
  • NO VHS tapes
  • NO R rated movies.  We accept up to PG-13.
  • NO Original Xbox games or consoles.  Must be 360 or newer.
  • NO Car seats or boosters unless new in box.
  • NO bottles with used nipples (can be sold without nipple if replacements are available), used sippy cups (can be sold if replacement mouth pieces are available), used pacifiers
  • NO breast pumps unless new in box
  • NO Potty Seats
  • NO Crib Bedding Sets or Mattresses (any size)
  • NO Free/Hospital Diaper Bags
  • NO Infant Formula, baby food or other edible items
  • NO room decor, art/wall hangings, lamps, rugs, knick-knacks, frames. Furniture is OK
  • Please consider donating Imagination Library books vs. selling them
  • NO SMOKE ODOR, PET HAIR OR PET ODOR. If you smoke in your home, your items will need to be freshly laundered with fabric softener to remove any odor.

Boutique & Designer Brands

  • Make it easy for shoppers to spot by securing ribbon on the neck of hanger.
  • Curling ribbon works best. Secure with a piece of tape so doesn’t fall off.
  • Use ribbon on brands like Matilda Jane, J Crew, Brooks Brothers, Persnickety, Burberry, Free People, Joe’s Jeans.
  • Gymboree, Gap and Ralph Lauren are great but NOT considered boutique.

Juniors & Young Men's Clothing

  • We accept Juniors sizes up to size XXL / size 17 / 36 waist
  • We accept Young Men’s sizes up to size XXL /  38 waist
  • We accept Shoes up to size 12

Sports Clothing
brands like:

  • Adidas
  • Columbia
  • Converse
  • Jordan
  • Lululemon
  • Nike
  • North Face
  • Puma
  • Patagonia
  • Under Armour
  • All College/NBA/NFL, etc apparel

Casual Clothing
brands like:

  • Abercrombie, Aeropostale
  • American Eagle, Hollister
  • PacSun, Roxy
  • Ralph Lauren, J Crew, Gap
  • Victoria’s Secret/PINK
  • Miss Me, Joe’s,
  • True Religion, Free People
  • Forever 21
  • Urban Outfitters, H&M
  • Vineyard Vines
  • Levi’s
  • Boutique Brands from places like Altar’d State, Folly, Hot Southern Mess, Josie’s, etc.

Brands Not Accepted
Budget brands like:

  • Target
  • Mossimo
  • WalMart
  • KMart
  • Rue 21
  • Charlotte Russe
    Ladies brands like:
  • Sonoma
  • Apt 9
  • Jessica Howard
  • St John’s Bay
  • Kim Rogers
  • Chaps
  • Nine West

Exceptions - for FALL SALE

• baby onesies worn under clothing or in dark/Fall colors.
• pajama sets with long bottoms in dark/Fall colors. No spring themes.
• polo, button ups, sweaters and T-shirts in dark or Fall colors are accepted.
• shirts with Valentine’s Day or St Patrick’s Day themes.
• name brand shirts in dark/Fall colors. Abercrombie, Hollister, etc.
• sports shirts such as Nike, Under Armour, etc.
• shirts/jerseys that have College or Professional Sports Teams.

• Keens & Chacos are accepted year round. No spring colors.
• White toddler walking shoes are accepted. NO other white shoes.

• Khaki or Navy Uniform shorts/skorts
• Athletic Shorts
• Thick corduroy and wool shorts
• Capri- denim only

Exceptions - for SPRING SALE

• light-weight infant layette
• shirts that are light weight fabric and/or spring colored
• sweaters that are light weight such as sweaters worn for Easter
• light-weight jackets, wind breakers & rain coats

• Cowboy Boots
• “On trend” short boots